The Vietnam War as portrayed by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick began airing on PBS stations and on-line (along with the next four episodes) this past Sunday.
Anti-war activists and academic experts who have previewed the whole series reach different conclusions about its treatment of the war and of the peace movement. Decide for yourself---but don't keep it a secret!
Everyone agrees the series is very well done and emotionally engaging. Many are calling it the definitive TV history of the war that will shape opinions of generations too young to remember. It will open long overdue conversations about what happened and why. Viewers can be challenged to consider current human costs in all four countries, as well as lessons for today's and tomorrow's military conflicts.
If you return our action form and indicate interest in the series, we will send you special updates analyzing every episode. They will also be posted on our web page.
If you "like" our
Facebook page, you can post comments after each episode and see how others are responding.
Resources
Professor Maurice Isserman's critical review of how the anti-war movement is treated has been posted by Dissent.
Professor Jerry Lempke criticizes the film makers as "masters of false balancing" in a review for Public Books.
Tom Fox who served with International Voluntary Service in Vietnam and became editor of the National Catholic Reporter has written a
review for NCR, "'The Vietnam War' Weaves a Narrative of Human Calamity". He mostly praises the series, but notes the absence of the experience of civilians who worked with NGOs in South Vietnam.
Ken Burns and Lynn Novick write in
The Atlantic "How the Vietnam War Broke the American Presidency."
The New York Times published its
review of the series. and a superb
article on "The Forgotten Victims of Agent Orange" by Viet Thanh Nguyen and Dick Hughes.
Links to additional published reviews and articles about the series are here.
The Full Disclosure project of Veterans For Peace raises questions about each episode.
Volunteers of America has created a detailed guide for viewing the series and
addressing moral injury.
Paths to PBS
about the war, both supporters and opponents.
Some stations have created a site for their own state, for example "Minnesota Remembers: The Story Wall" Andy Berman, an activist in Minneapolis who served in the Peace Corps and then joined the army to organize from within, posted
here
VPCC committee member Susan Hammond compiled information about
public stations' plans and PBS also issued a
summary. Check there and look at your station's web site to learn the latest about its plans and how you can become involved.
Fifty libraries nationwide are planning programs with the assistance of PBS. Others will use the series independently.
Reports from Preview Screenings
Most of the outreach events around the country featuring Burns and Novick have been carefully managed public relations events with often moving in-person comments by people who had been interviewed in the documentary. The most prestigious were at the Kennedy Center in Washington, D.C. and Lincoln Center in New York earlier this week. The
Washington audience heard from Senators Kerry and McCain who spoke proudly of their work for normal relations and reconciliation. Ken introduced both veterans and opponents of the war.
(Both events were marred by high level representatives of the corporate sponsor, the Bank of America, who insisted on asking only veterans in the audience to stand, but not "protestors". Maybe not too surprising.....BOA was targeted during anti-war demonstrations. A branch was burned in San Diego and a protester was killed there by police.)
The tone was very different at a local roll out by a Massachusetts public station. Professor Michael Klare, director of the Five College Program in Peace and World Security Studies, spoke passionately as an invited panelist. His scathing comments about the opening clip's characterization of good intentions for US intervention were quoted in the
Greenfield Recorder under the headline, "Wounds of war still raw as Vietnam documentary preview airs in Northampton."
**********************
No comments:
Post a Comment